"When a $1.5 million quarterback plays like he doesn’t care, fans and analysts will rip him apart—and that’s exactly what happened to Oregon State’s Maalik Murphy."
Former Washington State quarterback and Heisman Trophy finalist Ryan Leaf didn’t hold back in his critique of Oregon State’s Maalik Murphy during Saturday’s broadcast. With the Beavers trailing Wake Forest 15-0, Murphy’s three consecutive incomplete passes led to a punt—and Leaf’s fiery on-air takedown. But here’s the part that stings: Leaf didn’t just blame the plays; he accused Murphy of a lack of effort that’s costing the team dearly.
"It’s just so flippant," Leaf said during The CW’s coverage. "He has nobody pressuring him, yet he refuses to step into his throws. Instead, he lazily leans back and delivers weak, off-target passes. That’s why the ball keeps falling short."
Leaf doubled down, pointing out that Murphy’s inconsistent mechanics aren’t a one-time issue—they’ve plagued him all season. "Week after week, we see these moments where he treats his technique like an afterthought," Leaf argued. "That lack of discipline is killing Oregon State’s offense."
Murphy, who signed a $1.5 million NIL deal with Oregon State this offseason, entered the game with mediocre stats: a 59.7% completion rate, 1,523 passing yards, nine touchdowns, and seven interceptions. By the time this story was published, his performance had only worsened—completing just 3 of 11 passes for 36 yards as Wake Forest extended their lead to 22-0.
But here’s where it gets controversial: Not everyone agreed with Leaf’s harsh assessment. Fellow analyst Nigel Burton defended Murphy, suggesting Leaf was being too critical of the young quarterback. Leaf, however, stood firm: "He doesn’t look intentional. Sure, when you’re that athletic, maybe you can coast sometimes. But sloppy sidearm throws? No. If he led his receiver properly, that’s extra yards. Instead, he gifts the ball to defenders."
So, what’s the real problem? Is Murphy simply struggling under pressure, or is Leaf right—does he need to take the game more seriously? And with Oregon State now 0-6, how much of their losing streak falls on Murphy’s shoulders? Let’s debate: Is Leaf’s critique justified, or is he being too hard on a developing player? Sound off in the comments.
Game Details:
- Next Matchup: Oregon State (0-6) vs. Wake Forest (3-2)
- When: Saturday, Oct. 11
- Time: 12:30 p.m. PT
- Where: Reser Stadium
- TV: The CW (Channel 32 in Portland)
- Odds (as of Oct. 6): Wake Forest favored by 2.5; over/under 52.5
Note: By using this site, you consent to our User Agreement and Privacy Policy, including data collection by third-party partners.
