Cubs' Dilemma: Securing the Future of Cade Horton
The Cubs' front office faces a pivotal decision regarding the future of their young ace, Cade Horton. But here's the catch: it's a high-stakes gamble with an uncertain outcome.
Horton, the Cubs' top draft pick in 2022 from the University of Oklahoma, has shown immense potential. However, his journey has been marred by injuries, preventing him from showcasing his full potential until this year, where he pitched a career-high 147 innings.
A non-arm injury during the postseason raises questions. Could the Cubs' fate have been different if Horton had been healthy? This is the part that makes you wonder: is he injury-prone, or was it just bad luck?
Contract extensions for young pitchers are a risky business. Horton's injury history is a concern, but he was healthy in 2025 before a rib fracture this year. Should the Cubs take a chance on him?
With five years of team control remaining, the Cubs have options. They could play it safe, pay him through arbitration, and let him walk as a free agent. Or, they could make a bold move and lock him down for the long term.
A potential comparison is Garrett Crochet, who signed a lucrative extension with the Red Sox. Crochet, two years older than Horton, secured a six-year, $170 million deal after a strong season with the White Sox. But Horton's situation is unique, and the Cubs must decide if he's their cornerstone for the future.
Horton's performance this year suggests he could be a star. His 2.0 bWAR in 118 innings with the Cubs might have been even higher with a full season. But is this sustainable?
Here's a proposal: a three-year, $45 million contract with team options for the next three years at $20 million, $25 million, and $30 million. This structure provides flexibility and the potential for a six-year, $120 million commitment.
What do you think? Is this a fair offer for Horton? Should the Cubs take the risk? Share your thoughts and let's spark a discussion on this intriguing scenario!
Stay tuned for more insights on Monday.
